Pizza on Marco Island
Pizza at Sami's is stone baked and thin crust, made at 227 N Collier Blvd on Marco Island. The restaurant is open seven days a week. Pies come in a 14 inch medium (6 slices) and an 18 inch XL (8 slices), plus a 12 inch deep dish, a 12 inch gluten free crust and a 14 inch cauliflower crust.
A medium cheese pizza is $18.99. Order online for pickup or delivery, or dine in.
Pizza menu and prices
Sami's makes its pizza from in-house hand tossed dough and a house recipe sauce. The pizza is stone baked and thin crust, with a deep dish option. The prices below are from the dinner and to go menus; see the lunch menu for the lunch version.
Stone Baked Pizza
In-house hand tossed dough and house recipe pizza sauce. Thin crust, with a 12 inch deep dish also available.
Medium 14 in (6 slices)XL 18 in (8 slices)Deep Dish 12 inCauliflower Crust 14 inGluten Free 12 in
Cheese Pizza
Medium 14 in$18.99XL 18 in$21.99Deep Dish 12 in$22.99Cauliflower Crust 14 in$22.99Gluten Free 12 in$20.99Supreme Pizza
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, green peppers, onions & mushrooms.
Medium 14 in$26.99XL 18 in$29.99Deep Dish 12 in$29.99Cauliflower Crust 14 in$29.99Gluten Free 12 in$27.99Fresh Veggie Pizza
Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, tomatoes & black olives.
Medium 14 in$26.99XL 18 in$29.99Deep Dish 12 in$29.99Cauliflower Crust 14 in$29.99Gluten Free 12 in$27.99Margherita Pizza
Shredded mozzarella, fresh mozzarella cheese, fresh basil & diced tomatoes.
Medium 14 in$26.99XL 18 in$29.99Deep Dish 12 in$29.99Cauliflower Crust 14 in$29.99Gluten Free 12 in$26.99Meat Lover Pizza
Pepperoni, Italian sausage, meatballs, bacon & ham.
Medium 14 in$28.99XL 18 in$32.99Deep Dish 12 in$32.99Cauliflower Crust 14 in$29.99Gluten Free 12 in$28.99Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken, cheddar cheese, mozzarella cheese & drizzled with buffalo sauce.
Medium 14 in$27.99XL 18 in$30.99Deep Dish 12 in$30.99Cauliflower Crust 14 in$29.99Gluten Free 12 in$28.99Sami's Choice Pizza
Craft your pizza with any 5 of pizza (not gourmet) toppings.
Medium 14 in$27.99XL 18 in$30.99Deep Dish 12 in$30.99Cauliflower Crust 14 in$29.99Gluten Free 12 in$27.99White Pizza (No Sauce)
Choice of spinach or broccoli, roasted garlic, ricotta cheese & mozzarella.
Medium 14 in$26.99XL 18 in$30.99Deep Dish 12 in$30.99Cauliflower Crust 14 in$28.99Gluten Free 12 in$26.99Hawaiian Pizza
Smoked ham & pineapple.
Medium 14 in$25.99XL 18 in$29.99Deep Dish 12 in$29.99Cauliflower Crust 14 in$28.99Gluten Free 12 in$26.99Ultimate Pizza
Double crusted pizza, filled with mozzarella, spinach, meatballs, pepperoni, roasted red peppers & roasted garlic.
Medium 14 in$28.99XL 18 in$31.99Deep Dish 12 in$31.99Cauliflower Crust 14 in$29.99Gluten Free 12 in$27.99Chicken Alfredo Pizza
Chicken cutlets with alfredo sauce topped with mozzarella cheese. Substitute vodka sauce.
Medium 14 in$27.99XL 18 in$30.99Deep Dish 12 in$30.99Cauliflower Crust 14 in$29.99Gluten Free 12 in$27.99Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Ranch, spicy mango habanero, chicken, roasted red peppers & bacon bites.
Medium 14 in$27.99XL 18 in$30.99Deep Dish 12 in$30.99Cauliflower Crust 14 in$29.99Gluten Free 12 in$27.99
Pizza toppings: bacon, banana peppers, basil, black olives, broccoli, extra cheese, fresh garlic, roasted garlic, green olives, onions, green peppers, ham, meatballs, jalapenos, mushrooms, pepperoni, pineapple, tomatoes, feta cheese, ricotta cheese, provolone cheese, parmesan cheese, salami, sausage, kalamata olives, prosciutto and spinach. Medium $1.99, XL $2.99 each. Gourmet toppings: Alfredo sauce, fresh mozzarella, ground beef, roasted red peppers, anchovies and artichoke. Medium $2.99, XL $3.99. Chicken, gyro or ground beef: Medium $5.99, XL $7.99. Shrimp: Medium (4) $5.99, XL (6) $7.99.
Ginormous Calzone & Stromboli
Calzone
$19.99Stuffed with ricotta & mozzarella cheese, with your choice of ham, pepperoni, sausage or meatball. Additional toppings $1.49.
Stromboli
$19.99Stuffed with sausage, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese, green peppers, onions & mushrooms. Additional toppings $1.49. Add roasted red peppers $1.50.
Philly Cheesesteak Stromboli
$21.99Stuffed with steak smothered with sauteed onions & mushrooms, filled with mozzarella cheese.
Delivery fee applies. Add-ons may incur extra charges. For parties of 5 or more, a 20% gratuity is added. Menu prices and items are subject to change.
Sharing fee: $5 for pasta, $8 for other mains (comes with an additional side salad).
If you are allergic to peanut, soy or gluten, please be advised we are not a fully peanut, soy or gluten free kitchen. Gluten free choices are available. Consuming raw or uncooked meats, poultry, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.
Pizza at Sami's
Questions about Sami's on Marco Island
Where is the best pizza on Marco Island?
Sami's makes its pizza from in-house hand tossed dough and a house recipe sauce, baked stone style in 14 inch and 18 inch sizes, at 227 N Collier Blvd. Google Maps showed a 4.5 rating from 2,067 reviews on October 15, 2026.
Does Sami's deliver pizza on Marco Island?
Sami's menu says it delivers and a delivery fee applies. Order online through Toast or call (239) 389-7499 to confirm delivery to your address. Pickup and dine in are also available.
Does Sami's have gluten free pizza?
Yes. There is a 12 inch gluten free pizza and a 14 inch cauliflower crust, and the prices are listed above. Sami's notes that it is not a fully gluten free kitchen.
What sizes does Sami's pizza come in?
A medium is 14 inches with 6 slices and an XL is 18 inches with 8 slices. There is also a 12 inch deep dish, a 12 inch gluten free and a 14 inch cauliflower crust. A medium cheese pizza is $18.99 and an XL cheese pizza is $21.99.